Plan Insurance Blog

How Tenant Pets Could Cost Landlords Under New UK Reforms

For many landlords, tenant pets can be a bit of a conundrum. While four-legged friends might make tenants feel more at home, they can also spell trouble for property owners. Thanks to the proposed changes in the Renters Rights Bill, pet insurance and who picks up the tab could become a hot-button issue for buy-to-let investors across the UK.

What Exactly Does the Renters Rights Bill Propose?

Initially, the bill aimed to strike a fair balance. Tenants requesting pets would need to have their own pet insurance to cover any property damage. However, a recent amendment introduced in the House of Lords might flip the responsibility entirely, putting landlords on the hook for buying pet insurance themselves. This last-minute shift could significantly reshape landlord insurance for pet damage UK-wide.

Ben Beadle from the National Residential Landlords Association expressed his concerns: “Despite the provisions around pet insurance having been in the Bill since it was published, it’s only now that the government has decided suitable insurance products simply don’t exist.”

Why is Pet Insurance Becoming a Landlord Issue?

Under the proposed Renters Rights Bill pet policy, tenants will have a much easier time securing the right to keep pets. While landlords can’t refuse without good reason (think a Great Dane in a studio flat!), who covers accidental carpet stains or scratched-up doors is proving trickier.

Previously, tenants were expected to secure tenant pet damage insurance as part of their rental agreement. Now, this could all change, and landlords might need to take matters into their own hands.


Plan Insurance can accommodate your Property Owners & Landlord Insurance needs. Just fill in our short call back form, and our professional brokers will be in contact to arrange your insurance.


How Will This Impact the Rental Market?

With over 24% of landlords already planning to leave the rental market and another 23% selling properties, adding more costs could push even more investors out. Increased financial burdens, rising interest rates, and stricter regulations weigh heavily on buy-to-let insurance costs. If landlords also have to cover pet-related risks, it could trigger significant shifts in the rental landscape.

Tom Darling from the Renters’ Reform Coalition argues tenants shouldn’t shoulder extra financial burdens: “Tenants already pay a deposit and are liable for damages, so additional fees or insurance should not be necessary.”

A Possible Middle Ground: Pet Damage Deposits?

Another proposal suggests landlords could arrange insurance themselves, with tenants paying an additional pet damage deposit of up to three months’ rent. This deposit could specifically cover pet-related damage, offering a buffer for landlords without outright shifting insurance premiums onto tenants.

What Should Landlords Do Next?

While nothing is yet set in stone, landlords need to stay alert. Review your current buy-to-let insurance to understand what pet-related damages (if any) are covered. Start budgeting now for potential additional premiums. Landlords may also consider drafting clear pet policies to manage expectations and clarify responsibilities with tenants.

For further clarification, it is highly recommended that you consult reputable landlord insurance providers such as Plan or check detailed guidelines from the National Residential Landlords Association.

The Bottom Line

Ultimately, the impact of pets on rental properties UK-wide could grow considerably once the Renters Rights Bill becomes law. Whether you’re already welcoming tenant pets or wary of future bills, staying informed and proactive is key.

After all, pets might be family, but understanding the implications of pet insurance could help landlords avoid a financial bite.


Find out why 96% of our customers have rated us 4 stars or higher, by reading our reviews on Feefo.

To get a quote give our specialist teams a call on 0800 542 2743 or request a Call Back.

Already a client? Why not recommend us to your contacts in exchange for a £50 discount off your